Skip to content

Tough PLA vs PLA+: Tensile Strength, Impact Resistance and Stiffness Compared

Close-up of two 3D printer filament spools labeled Tough PLA and PLA+ with color-coded bars representing…

Tough PLA, PLA+, and PLA Pro are not standardized material grades. They are manufacturer-specific names for modified PLA formulations, and two spools carrying similar marketing labels can have very different tensile strength, stiffness, elongation, impact behavior, and heat resistance. Compare the exact product datasheet and test method rather than assuming that every Tough PLA or every PLA+ follows one recipe.

Manufacturer-specific Tough PLA and PLA+/PLA Pro examples compared using published printed-part data. The labels are not standardized formulations, and different test methods should not be treated as directly interchangeable.
Market LabelManufacturer-Specific ExamplePublished Tensile ValuePublished ModulusPublished Elongation at BreakPublished Impact ValuePublished Heat ResistanceWhat This Example Shows
Tough PLAUltiMaker Tough PLA45.3 MPa tensile stress at yield, XY2797 MPa tensile modulus, XY9.4%, XY8.9 kJ/m² Charpy, notched, XY58.3 °C HDT at 0.455 MPaA fairly stiff modified PLA with more ductile behavior than standard PLA and published yielding before break.[a]
Tough PLAcolorFabb Tough PLA55 MPa tensile strength2550 MPa Young’s modulus8.6%5.8 kJ/m² Charpy notchedNot listed for the 3D-printed specimen setA custom toughened PLA formulation with lower stiffness and higher elongation than colorFabb’s own Economy PLA example.[h]
PLA ProPolymaker PLA Pro39.93 MPa tensile strength, X-Y2531.08 MPa Young’s modulus, X-Y16.57%, X-Y20.76 kJ/m² notched Charpy, X-Y58.1 °C HDT at 0.45 MPaA current PLA Pro formulation with high published impact performance and relatively high elongation rather than maximum tensile strength.[b]
PLA+eSUN PLA+ Version 2.053.34 MPa tensile strength, X-Y2888.22 MPa flexural modulus, X-Y4.11%, X-Y5.5 kJ/m² Izod, X-Y53 °C HDT at 0.45 MPaA current PLA+ example with a different stiffness, elongation, and impact balance from Polymaker PLA Pro despite both sitting in the modified-PLA market.[d]

The table uses manufacturer-specific published values. Tensile yield, tensile break, Young’s modulus, flexural modulus, Charpy impact, and Izod impact are different measurements, so small cross-brand numerical differences should not be ranked as if every specimen and test method were identical.

Most people use stronger as if it meant one simple thing, but modified PLA datasheets split that idea into tensile strength, stiffness, elongation, impact behavior, interlayer strength, and heat resistance. That is why one Tough PLA can beat a PLA+ or PLA Pro in one test and trail it in another. The product name alone does not establish the mechanical ranking.

Tough PLA vs PLA+ Terminology

Tough PLA, PLA+, and PLA Pro do not describe one industry-defined recipe. Manufacturers use these names for their own modified PLA formulations, and the amount or type of impact modifier, process aid, pigment, filler, or other additive is not standardized across brands.

When someone searches for tough PLA vs PLA, the useful comparison is usually a specific toughened PLA against that manufacturer’s regular PLA. A search for PLA+ vs Tough PLA is different: both sides may already be modified PLA products, so there is no reliable family-level winner without product-specific test data.

The naming can also change while the material category stays similar. Polymaker now sells Polymaker PLA Pro as its current toughened high-speed PLA Pro formulation and is replacing the older PolyLite PLA Pro line, which is scheduled for discontinuation by the end of 2026.[j] Mechanical values from the older PolyLite PLA Pro datasheet should not automatically be assigned to the newer Polymaker PLA Pro formula.

Use the label to find the product family, then use the datasheet to choose the spool. A manufacturer may tune one PLA+ toward rigidity, another toward impact resistance, and another toward elongation or high-speed printing. Those products can share a similar retail name without sharing the same mechanical balance.

What Tough PLA and PLA+ Usually Mean

These labels usually point toward PLA formulations modified to reduce the brittle behavior associated with basic PLA, but the target varies by manufacturer. UltiMaker describes Tough PLA as a technical PLA with toughness comparable to its ABS and positions it for functional prototypes and tooling.[c] colorFabb describes Tough PLA as a custom blend that retains PLA printability while raising impact strength.[h]

PLA+ and PLA Pro names are just as variable. Current Polymaker PLA Pro is designed around impact resistance, higher-speed printing, and easy PLA processing, while current eSUN PLA+ publishes a different mechanical profile and uses its own GB/T test set.[b][d] Neither name defines a mandatory tensile strength, impact value, modifier percentage, or elongation range.

What “Stronger” Means on a Filament Datasheet

Tensile Strength
This describes stress under a defined tensile test. A datasheet may report yield strength, break strength, or both, so the exact column heading matters.[e]
Young’s Modulus
This describes tensile stiffness. A higher value usually means the specimen resists elastic stretching more strongly.
Flexural Modulus
This describes stiffness during bending. It should not be silently substituted for Young’s modulus when comparing products.
Elongation at Break
This shows how far the specimen stretches before failure. Higher values can indicate a more ductile response, but they do not directly measure impact resistance.
Impact Strength
Charpy and Izod tests measure resistance to a sudden strike under defined specimen and notch conditions. Values from different impact methods are not direct equivalents.[f]
HDT
Heat deflection temperature measures deformation under a specified load as temperature rises. The applied stress must be checked before comparing values.[g]

If you care about a rigid bracket, tensile or flexural modulus may matter more than maximum elongation. If the part will be dropped, clipped into place, bent during assembly, or hit repeatedly, impact strength, yield behavior, and elongation deserve more attention. A single “strength” number cannot answer all of those cases.

Where Tough PLA Can Differ From Standard PLA

Tough PLA products are commonly developed to reduce brittle failure, but the size of that change depends on the formulation. UltiMaker Tough PLA yields before breaking in its printed tensile test and reaches 9.4% elongation at break in XY.[a] colorFabb Tough PLA reports 8.6% elongation for its printed specimen set and says its formulation raises impact strength by roughly 70% compared with its regular PLA reference.[h]

That kind of behavior can help clips, housings, assembly features, prototypes, and parts likely to be knocked during use. It does not mean every product carrying the Tough PLA name will be softer, more impact-resistant, or more ductile than every PLA+ product. The current Polymaker PLA Pro example in the opening table has both higher published elongation and higher notched Charpy impact than the two Tough PLA examples shown there.

Compare Tough PLA With the Manufacturer’s Standard PLA When Possible

A same-brand comparison removes some uncertainty because the manufacturer is more likely to use related specimen preparation and test methods. Cross-brand labels are useful for discovery, but they are weaker evidence for a mechanical ranking.

Why PLA+ and PLA Pro Can Look Very Different on Paper

The current Polymaker PLA Pro and eSUN PLA+ data show why PLA+ cannot be treated as one fixed material family. Polymaker PLA Pro lists 39.93 MPa X-Y tensile strength, 16.57% X-Y elongation, 2531.08 MPa Young’s modulus, and 20.76 kJ/m² notched Charpy impact strength.[b]

eSUN PLA+ Version 2.0 instead lists 53.34 MPa X-Y tensile strength, 4.11% X-Y elongation, 2888.22 MPa X-Y flexural modulus, and 5.5 kJ/m² X-Y Izod impact strength.[d] The modulus and impact methods are different, so those figures should not be turned into a direct numerical score. They still make one point very clearly: two modified PLA products can target noticeably different mechanical behavior.

Current Polymaker PLA Pro is also a new formulation rather than a renamed spool carrying the older PolyLite PLA Pro mechanical sheet. Its manufacturer page states that the current product replaces PolyLite PLA Pro and adds high-speed printing capability up to 300 mm/s.[j]

The Trade-Off Behind Toughened PLA Blends

Toughening a PLA formulation can change stiffness, tensile behavior, elongation, and impact response at the same time. The direction is not identical for every recipe. A useful same-brand example comes from colorFabb: its Economy PLA sheet lists 3300 MPa modulus, 70 MPa tensile strength, 3.5% elongation, and 4.0 kJ/m² Charpy impact strength for printed samples, while its Tough PLA lists 2550 MPa modulus, 55 MPa tensile strength, 8.6% elongation, and 5.8 kJ/m² impact strength.[i]

Within that manufacturer’s data, the Tough PLA is less stiff and lower in tensile strength, but it stretches farther before break and records a higher notched impact value. That is a more useful way to read a toughened formulation than asking whether it is simply “stronger.”

Why One Tough PLA Can Trail Another PLA+

  • The formulations are manufacturer-specific. Tough PLA, PLA+, and PLA Pro names do not impose a shared modifier package or performance target.
  • Test method changes the result. Tensile yield, tensile break, Young’s modulus, flexural modulus, Charpy impact, and Izod impact answer different questions.[e]
  • Print orientation changes the result. UltiMaker Tough PLA publishes different XY, YZ, and Z tensile values because FFF parts are anisotropic.[a]
  • Specimen preparation matters. Current Polymaker PLA Pro uses 100% infill printed specimens and lists its printing conditions in the TDS, while eSUN PLA+ also publishes its own 100% infill test setup.[b][d]
  • Small numerical gaps are often weaker than they look. Cross-brand values should only be ranked when the test type, orientation, conditioning, and specimen preparation are reasonably comparable.

Choosing Between Tough PLA and PLA+

If You Need a Stiff Part

Check Young’s modulus or flexural modulus for the exact products. Do not assume PLA+ is always stiffer or Tough PLA is always softer. The current examples overlap too much for a reliable category-level rule.

If You Need Better Impact Behavior

Look for a published Charpy or Izod test with the notch condition and specimen direction stated. Current Polymaker PLA Pro, UltiMaker Tough PLA, colorFabb Tough PLA, and eSUN PLA+ publish very different impact figures and do not all use the same impact method.

If You Need More Ductile Failure

Check elongation, yield behavior, and the printed stress-strain data where available. A product that yields or stretches farther before failure may suit clips and assembly features better even when its tensile-strength number is lower.

If You Are Choosing by the Name on the Box

Stop at the label only long enough to identify the product category. The final choice should use the manufacturer’s current formulation, current technical sheet, print orientation, and the property that matters for the part.

A Tough PLA vs PLA+ comparison therefore has no permanent category winner. One specific Tough PLA may have better impact or elongation than one PLA+, while another PLA+ or PLA Pro may reverse that result. Product-specific formulation and comparable test data are more useful than the naming convention.

Resources Used

Author

Beverly Damon N. is the founder of FilamentCompare. She created the site to make filament specifications and material differences easier to understand. Comparisons are based mainly on manufacturer datasheets, published technical information, and relevant third-party sources. FilamentCompare does not present these comparisons as independent laboratory tests unless a page clearly states that original testing was conducted.View Author posts