| Attribute | Nylon (FFF/FDM Filament) | Engineering Resin (SLA/DLP) |
|---|---|---|
| What It Is | A thermoplastic polyamide that softens with heat and can be re-melted. Many nylon filaments are semi-crystalline and respond strongly to moisture conditioning. | A UV-curable photopolymer that forms a crosslinked network. Mechanical properties depend on the resin formulation, degree of cure, and post-processing conditions. |
| Tensile Strength, Stiffness, and Elongation |
Polymaker PolyMide CoPA (TDS V5.5, January 2026) reports the following printed-specimen values:
|
Formlabs Tough 2000 Resin V2 reports:
|
| Flexural Strength and Stiffness | PolyMide CoPA reports 109.8 MPa XY flexural strength and 2,510 MPa flexural modulus in dry condition. Its wet-status figures are 22.6 MPa and 636 MPa, respectively, under ISO 178 / GB/T 9341. | Tough 2000 Resin V2 reports 67 MPa flexural strength and 1,701 MPa flexural modulus after post-curing, compared with 38 MPa and 1,040 MPa in the green condition under ASTM D790. |
| Impact and Notch Behavior | PolyMide CoPA reports 6.9 kJ/m² notched Charpy impact strength in dry condition and 27.7 kJ/m² in wet condition, measured in the XY orientation. | Tough 2000 Resin V2 reports 25 J/m notched Izod impact strength after post-curing. Charpy and Izod measurements use different test configurations and cannot be ranked by comparing their numerical values directly. |
| Heat Under Load (HDT) | PolyMide CoPA reports 70°C at 1.8 MPa and 111°C at 0.45 MPa under ISO 75. These are the manufacturer’s reported thermal values, not separately identified dry/wet HDT results. | Post-cured Tough 2000 Resin V2 reports 57°C at 1.8 MPa and 70°C at 0.45 MPa under ASTM D648. Other engineering resin formulations can have different thermal ratings. |
| Water Interaction | Nylon absorbs moisture, changing its stiffness, strength, and deformation behavior. The conditioning state must be identified when interpreting mechanical results. | Engineering resins also interact with water, although absorption and resulting property changes depend on the cured chemistry. Post-curing and environmental exposure should be considered separately. |
| Precision and Surface Finish | Nylon FFF parts can provide durable functional performance. Fine detail and dimensional accuracy depend on nozzle size, layer height, shrinkage, and cooling conditions. | SLA/DLP processes can reproduce fine features and smooth surfaces. Accuracy also depends on resin shrinkage, orientation, support placement, washing, and post-curing. |
| Typical Functional Applications | Brackets, hinges, clips, fixtures, wear-resistant interfaces, and assemblies requiring toughness or controlled flexibility. | Jigs, fixtures, housings, accurate mating parts, snap-fit components, and assemblies benefiting from smooth surfaces and detailed geometry. |
Comparison limit: These are manufacturer-published values, not results from a single head-to-head experiment. CoPA nylon is reported using ISO/GB tensile methods, while Tough 2000 Resin V2 uses ASTM methods; specimen preparation, moisture state, curing, orientation, and test conditions differ. The numbers describe individual products and should not be treated as directly interchangeable strength rankings.
Comparing nylon FDM filament and engineering resin requires more than placing two tensile-strength figures side by side. The values in this article come from manufacturer technical datasheets for Polymaker PolyMide CoPA, Formlabs Tough 2000 Resin V2, and LOCTITE 3D 3843 HDT60. They do not represent a new laboratory test performed under identical conditions. Each product’s material state, conditioning, and test method helps explain what its published strength figures mean.
- Manufacturer Datasheet Values
- Dry vs Moisture-Conditioned Nylon
- Green vs Post-Cured Resin
- XY and Z Orientation
- ISO vs ASTM Methods
- HDT Under Defined Load
What the Reported Strength Measurements Mean
- Tensile Strength and Modulus
- Tensile testing measures how a specimen behaves when pulled. Strength describes stress at a defined point, such as yield or break; modulus describes elastic stiffness. ISO 527 establishes general principles for measuring tensile properties of plastics and composites.[f]
- Flexural Strength and Flexural Modulus
- Flexural testing measures how a specimen responds to bending. ISO 178 describes a three-point bending method used to determine flexural strength, modulus, and related deformation characteristics.[g]
- Impact Strength
- Impact tests measure the response of a specimen to a rapid applied load. Notched and unnotched tests can produce different results, while Charpy and Izod methods use different arrangements and reporting conventions. ISO 180 defines Izod impact testing procedures.[j]
- Heat Deflection Temperature (HDT)
- HDT records the temperature at which a specimen reaches a defined deflection under a specified flexural stress. ISO 75 defines the general test approach. HDT is not a melting temperature or a universal continuous-service temperature.[h]
- Water Absorption and Moisture Uptake
- Water absorption testing measures moisture uptake under defined exposure conditions. ISO 62 covers procedures involving water immersion and controlled humid atmospheres, allowing environmental effects on plastics to be evaluated.[i]
Material Identity: Nylon vs UV Resin Is a Structure Difference
Nylon filaments are polyamides and belong to the thermoplastic materials commonly discussed among engineering-grade 3D printing filaments. Temperature, moisture, and thermal history affect molecular mobility, crystallinity, stiffness, and energy absorption. Two nylon components printed from the same material can therefore show different mechanical responses when their moisture content or conditioning history differs.
PolyMide CoPA is based on a copolymer of Nylon 6 and Nylon 6,6. Its mechanical behavior is not representative of every PA6, PA12, PA66, or fiber-reinforced nylon filament. The manufacturer reports separate dry and wet material properties, making it a useful example of how environmental conditioning affects printed nylon.
Engineering resins used in SLA and DLP printing cure through photopolymerization. The resulting crosslinked structure is influenced by resin chemistry, light exposure, and any subsequent UV or thermal post-curing. Academic work on photopolymer material modeling has demonstrated relationships between light intensity, temperature, crosslinking, and mechanical response.[k]
This structural difference explains why nylon moisture conditioning and resin post-curing need separate treatment in a strength comparison. They change material properties through different physical and chemical processes.
Tensile and Flexural: Reading the Numbers by Material State
Why One Tensile Strength Value Is Not Enough
For nylon, moisture uptake can reduce stiffness and tensile strength while changing deformation behavior. Resin properties often change as the specified curing process is completed. A meaningful comparison identifies the tested material state alongside the strength value instead of treating the highest reported number as a universal property.
The Polymaker CoPA figures illustrate this point. Its January 2026 technical datasheet, version 5.5, gives a dry XY tensile strength of 78.0 ± 0.7 MPa and a wet-status value of 34.3 ± 2.5 MPa. Young’s modulus changes from 2,703 ± 259 MPa in dry condition to 724 ± 61 MPa in wet condition. The manufacturer separately reports XY elongation at break of 12.7 ± 2.1% and 13.2 ± 2.3% for those states.
These values replace the older CoPA datasheet figures of 66.2 MPa and 31.4 MPa XY tensile strength, which belonged to an earlier technical-sheet revision. The current version also reports different modulus and elongation values. Data from separate revisions should not be combined as though they describe one identical specimen set.
For Formlabs Tough 2000 Resin V2, the post-cured tensile strength is 40.4 MPa, compared with 26.1 MPa in the washed green condition. Tensile modulus increases from 1,235 to 1,800 MPa, while elongation at break changes from 149% to 79%. These are manufacturer-reported results for a defined Form 4 printing and post-processing procedure.
The flexural figures follow the same need for context. CoPA’s dry XY flexural strength is reported as 109.8 MPa, compared with 22.6 MPa in wet condition. Tough 2000 Resin V2 reports 67 MPa after post-curing and 38 MPa before post-curing. The nylon and resin figures come from different test standards and specimen preparation procedures, so the numerical comparison is descriptive rather than a controlled ranking.
Manufacturer Test Conditions Behind the Values
| Material and State | Specimen Preparation | Relevant Test Methods |
|---|---|---|
| PolyMide CoPA — Dry | Manufacturer-designated dry-status printed specimens. The V5.5 sheet identifies its specimen printing setup, including 100% infill, and reports dry mechanical properties separately. | ISO 527 / GB/T 1040 for tensile measurements; ISO 178 / GB/T 9341 for flexural measurements. |
| PolyMide CoPA — Wet | Manufacturer-designated wet-status specimens. V5.5 reports the wet mechanical dataset but does not provide a complete humidity-conditioning schedule for those tests in the published table. | ISO 527 / GB/T 1040 for tensile measurements; ISO 178 / GB/T 9341 for flexural measurements. |
| Tough 2000 Resin V2 — Green | Printed on a Form 4 with 100 µm settings and washed in 99% IPA using a Form Wash V2 for 10 + 5 minutes. No subsequent Form Cure V2 treatment was applied to this reported state. | ASTM D638 for tensile; ASTM D790 for flexural; ASTM D256 for notched Izod. |
| Tough 2000 Resin V2 — Post-Cured | Same Form 4 printing and washing procedure, followed by 70°C for 12 minutes in a Form Cure V2. | ASTM D638 for tensile; ASTM D790 for flexural; ASTM D256 for notched Izod. |
| LOCTITE 3D 3843 HDT60 Matte Black — Post-Processed | Manufacturer-defined printed and post-processed specimen condition. The referenced technical sheet specifies laboratory conditioning at 19–23°C and 40–60% RH for at least 24 hours and describes validated post-curing procedures. | ASTM D638 for tensile; ASTM D790 for flexural; ASTM D256 for notched Izod; ASTM D648 for HDT. |
The conditions differ even before the measurements begin. A dry nylon specimen, a moisture-conditioned nylon specimen, a washed resin specimen, and a post-cured resin specimen are four distinct test states. Matching the nominal material category is not enough to establish equivalent test conditions.
Impact and Notch Behavior: Toughness Depends on the Test
In mechanical applications, toughness describes a material’s ability to absorb energy before failure. Nylon can dissipate energy through plastic deformation, with moisture conditioning often changing the balance between stiffness and deformation. Engineering resins marketed for toughness use formulations intended to withstand impact and mechanical loading while retaining useful dimensional accuracy.
PolyMide CoPA’s V5.5 datasheet reports notched Charpy impact strength of 6.9 ± 1.4 kJ/m² in dry condition and 27.7 ± 1.2 kJ/m² in wet condition for XY specimens. These figures show a substantial difference between the two manufacturer-reported nylon states.
Formlabs Tough 2000 Resin V2 reports 25 J/m notched Izod impact strength after post-curing and 325 J/m unnotched Izod under its specified ASTM procedures. Those results describe different impact configurations. They should also remain separate from CoPA’s Charpy values, since test geometry, notch preparation, loading arrangement, and units differ.
For clips, snap-fit assemblies, and fixtures exposed to sudden loads, impact measurements complement tensile and flexural data. A higher tensile-strength value does not by itself establish better impact performance.
Heat Under Load: HDT and Test Conditions
Heat deflection temperature describes how a specimen deforms under a specified load as temperature rises. It is useful for understanding temperature-dependent stiffness in brackets, clips, and fixtures, although it does not directly predict continuous service life or long-term creep.
Polymaker CoPA reports 70°C at 1.8 MPa and 111°C at 0.45 MPa in its V5.5 datasheet. Formlabs Tough 2000 Resin V2 reports 57°C at 1.8 MPa and 70°C at 0.45 MPa after post-curing. LOCTITE 3D 3843 HDT60 Matte Black reports 63°C at 0.455 MPa after post-processing.
These data illustrate the influence of test load and material preparation. The two nominal stress levels, approximately 0.45 and 1.8 MPa, produce different HDT values even for the same product. The testing standards and specimen conditions also need to be considered when comparing one material with another.
HDT is not a continuous-use temperature. A manufacturer’s description of heat resistance, Vicat softening temperature, melting temperature, and HDT may refer to different measurements. For a comparison involving a loaded printed component, the HDT load and test state should be stated alongside the temperature.
Water and Time: Conditioning Changes the Results
Mechanical properties can change when plastic specimens are tested after different moisture exposures. This matters especially for polyamides, where absorbed water interacts with polymer chains and alters stiffness, strength, and ductility. ISO 291 establishes standard atmospheres for conditioning and testing plastic specimens.[e]
For CoPA, the difference between the manufacturer’s dry and wet datasets is particularly visible in tensile strength and modulus. The current V5.5 sheet also reports an equilibrium water absorption value of approximately 2.82% at 70% relative humidity and 23°C in its moisture absorption reference. That equilibrium measurement should not be assumed to be the exact conditioning procedure used for every wet mechanical specimen.
The older CoPA datasheet identified a separate conditioning procedure involving 70% relative humidity for 15 days. Since the current V5.5 mechanical table does not explicitly carry that same preparation schedule, its revised wet-status figures should be reported without automatically importing the earlier procedure.
Engineering resins also respond to environmental exposure, but the mechanisms and rates depend on the cured polymer network. For the LOCTITE 3D 3843 Matte Black formulation, the manufacturer reports 1.94% water absorption after 24 hours using ASTM D570. That figure describes a defined immersion measurement and is not directly equivalent to CoPA’s equilibrium moisture absorption value.
Process Effects: Orientation and Settings Affect Strength
Nylon FFF/FDM parts can exhibit mechanical anisotropy because bonding between deposited layers differs from strength within the layer plane. Resin parts may show a different degree of directional variation, but their properties can still depend on orientation, exposure conditions, geometry, and post-curing.
The Polymaker CoPA values show why separate XY and Z measurements are useful. In dry condition, the manufacturer reports 78.0 MPa tensile strength in XY and 45.8 MPa in Z. In wet condition, the corresponding values are 34.3 and 13.7 MPa. These are results for a particular printed material and preparation method, not universal nylon strength ratios.
Resin orientation and processing can also influence mechanical properties. The Formlabs Tough 2000 Resin V2 datasheet specifies its Form 4 printing and curing conditions while noting that actual results vary with part geometry, print orientation, settings, and temperature.
Information Reported in Mechanical Test Documentation
- Material name and grade: the exact nylon formulation, engineering resin, and any reinforcing or toughening additives.
- Manufacturing process: FFF/FDM, SLA, or DLP, including the relevant printing equipment and orientation.
- Conditioning state: dry, moisture-conditioned, ambient-conditioned, or immersed specimens.
- Post-processing: nylon annealing where applicable, resin washing, and the specified UV or thermal cure.
- Test methods: tensile, flexural, impact, and HDT standards, along with specimen geometry.
- Reported variability: specimen counts, averages, standard deviations, or other uncertainty information when supplied.
A Second Resin Reference Point: LOCTITE 3D 3843 HDT60
Engineering resins cover a wide range of mechanical properties, so Tough 2000 Resin V2 should not be treated as representative of every SLA or DLP formulation. LOCTITE 3D 3843 HDT60 provides another useful example, particularly for functional fixtures and manufacturing aids.
The LOCTITE 3D 3843 HDT60 Matte Black technical sheet reports post-processed tensile stress at break of 51 ± 2 MPa, Young’s modulus of 1,806 ± 47 MPa, elongation at break of 43 ± 10%, and notched Izod impact strength of 53 ± 4 J/m. It also lists an HDT of 63°C at 0.455 MPa and 24-hour water absorption of 1.94%.[c]
These figures apply specifically to the Matte Black formulation and the manufacturer’s post-processed test state. LOCTITE 3D 3843 is also available in other colors with separate published properties. Its Matte Black values should not automatically be assigned to the Clear or White formulations.
Henkel specifies that LOCTITE 3D 3843 Matte Black requires post-curing to achieve its published performance. Its technical documentation describes validated procedures involving cleaning, drying, and UV curing. The final part properties depend on following the applicable product and printer-specific processing conditions.
For example, the 51 MPa post-processed tensile stress at break reported for LOCTITE 3D 3843 Matte Black and the 40.4 MPa ultimate tensile strength reported for post-cured Tough 2000 Resin V2 come from different manufacturers and specimen procedures. They illustrate differences between two engineering resin formulations without establishing a controlled, identical-condition comparison.
Comparing the Reported Product Values
| Measured Property | PolyMide CoPA | Tough 2000 Resin V2 | LOCTITE 3D 3843 Matte Black |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tensile Strength | 78.0 MPa dry XY; 34.3 MPa wet XY | 40.4 MPa post-cured | 51 MPa at break, post-processed |
| Tensile Modulus | 2,703 MPa dry XY; 724 MPa wet XY | 1,800 MPa post-cured | 1,806 MPa post-processed |
| Elongation at Break | 12.7% dry XY; 13.2% wet XY | 79% post-cured | 43% post-processed |
| Flexural Modulus | 2,510 MPa dry XY; 636 MPa wet XY | 1,701 MPa post-cured | 1,783 MPa post-processed |
| Notched Impact | 6.9 kJ/m² dry XY; 27.7 kJ/m² wet XY (Charpy) | 25 J/m post-cured (Izod) | 53 J/m post-processed (Izod) |
| HDT at Approximately 0.45 MPa | 111°C (reported thermal value) | 70°C post-cured | 63°C post-processed |
| HDT at Approximately 1.8 MPa | 70°C (reported thermal value) | 57°C post-cured | Not included in the cited 2023 Matte Black property table |
| Tensile Test Method | ISO 527 / GB/T 1040 | ASTM D638 | ASTM D638 |
| Reported Material State | Separate dry and wet datasets | Printed, washed, and post-cured | Printed and post-processed |
The table retains the manufacturer’s reported units and specimen states. Charpy impact values are not directly comparable with Izod values, and tensile or flexural results obtained under ISO and ASTM procedures should not be treated as one controlled dataset. The measured properties are useful for understanding each product’s behavior under its published conditions.
Resources Used
- [a] Polymaker — PolyMide CoPA Technical Data Sheet, Version 5.5, January 2026 (PDF)
- [b] Formlabs — Tough 2000 Resin V2 Technical Data Sheet, October 2025 (PDF)
- [c] Henkel LOCTITE — LOCTITE 3D 3843 HDT60 High Toughness Technical Data Sheet, January 2023 (PDF)
- [e] ISO — ISO 291:2008, Plastics: Standard Atmospheres for Conditioning and Testing
- [f] ISO — ISO 527-1:2019, Plastics: Determination of Tensile Properties, General Principles
- [g] ISO — ISO 178:2019, Plastics: Determination of Flexural Properties
- [h] ISO — ISO 75-1:2020, Plastics: Determination of Temperature of Deflection Under Load
- [i] ISO — ISO 62:2008, Plastics: Determination of Water Absorption
- [j] ISO — ISO 180:2023, Plastics: Determination of Izod Impact Strength
- [k] Solid Freeform Fabrication Symposium — Material Modelling of the Photopolymers for Additive Manufacturing Processes, 2022 (PDF)